Finish owner full-suite review and landing. Round-4 author correction is FIXED and pushed at f4ae328ce43ca766ac1f1358b8d184142edbd4de: 34 first-attempt greens, nine intended product-only reverted assertion reds, and all 2,006 input hashes match. PR remains OPEN/unmerged; no queue or deploy.
Written 2026-10-28 11:42 UTC. RE-VERIFY https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/pull/743 with gh pr view --json headRefOid,state before owner action. Verified OPEN/unmerged at f4ae328ce43ca766ac1f1358b8d184142edbd4de. Latest-main rebase was unchanged; exact-lease publication advanced the shared source from c4b30ab1d21c4686eabd911e2561b3e8c1b2d037. The source checkout is clean.
The service archives the entire handoff when a report uses status DONE; it also clears the claim. The limited W4 author assignment is complete, but the wider owner work is not, so W4 reopened this handoff and verified ORANGE/unclaimed with completedAtMs=null. Reserve DONE for completion of this entire tracked handoff. Limited author completions should update the body and release their claim without sending DONE. No source change, merge, queue entry or deployment followed the verified author push.
The current author brief says: "Do NOT merge, enqueue, deploy. Stop when pushed and the targeted tests pass first-attempt. Further verification past that is a failure to follow this brief." "Never change timeouts, iterations or assertions' strength." "Do not run a full local suite; the PR's bld-build check on the GitHub runner is the full-suite gate." The limited author assignment is now DONE/FIXED. The owner retains the wider full-suite/review/landing assignment, so this handoff remains open and must not be archived merely because these author corrections were pushed.
F1: removal ownership is fully in the directory name before mkdir/rename, with creator PID/start and original parent/target identity fingerprints. Certificate generation/root, deleted-route, temporary-history and launcher startup revisit and finish matching empty removals after the creator exits. Live owners, replaced or nonempty targets, links and unrecognized inputs are preserved. F2: 15 existing tests now assert public constructor recovery, process-group cleanup, PID-store outcomes and eventual whole-directory removal; negative inputs and actual process setup remain.
The required gap search added seven actual process-death directory scenarios, an eighth real pointer-publication cleanup interruption, and a ninth malformed/mismatched-removal input scenario. The pointer temporary now belongs to its newly created generation before pointer publication. A stale alias fixture was corrected to require pending cleanup while another saved registration remains, then preserve its original success assertion after public final-reference retirement. No process-cleanup product code was weakened for that fixture.
Final native proof: 34/34 first-attempt greens, then nine intended product-only assertion reds; zero attempt histories. All 2,006 source/build/test/script input hashes match the published source; reversal changes exactly the six intended product files and restored product hashes match green. Every targeted command explicitly races local/remote on a disposable GitHub runner; local execution completes despite remote startup health rejection. No full local suite, altered test limits, CI retries or verification beyond the limited author gate.
Initial assertion-red evidence: certificate and route/history boundaries, launcher input, pointer publication, nested route and unchanged-product alias baseline. The six-case test proof succeeded; its separate automatic archive push was refused for workflow-file permission, so its native artifacts were preserved through the author-owned evidence branch. No test was retried.
Complete evidence and requested result contain native XML, complete assertion stacks, hashes/publication audit, dedicated source/test review passes, all executor controls, prior candidate history and W4 result JSON. The initial candidate's 31/32 and a superseded cancelled candidate are explicitly excluded from final-green claims. No generated keys, binaries or dependency caches are committed. The PR description is updated with the same evidence and the historical PID-stress answer.
The historical 100-second FutureTask / 120-second watchdog failures followed by 63.927-second / 80.874-second passes remain unexplained without a matched same-runner before/after mechanism. No performance fix or current-head attribution is claimed; persisted cleanup retries are not timing-fix evidence.
No deployed or Maven-published code from this author assignment exists. Source is committed and pushed to the open PR; no merge or queue entry was requested. All author native proof jobs and watchers are terminal, and no owned local test JVM is left running. No further runtime verification follows publication.
| Branch | Verified remote head | Role |
|---|---|---|
| wip/w4-103110-evidence | e0f584ec7f388f314720176f5d805abf03f5afba | Author checkpoint/proof/evidence; no separate PR |
| wip/w4-103110-final-candidate | 59efb46135bf1277b5659f49338a92cb28ed456b | Author checkpoint/proof/evidence; no separate PR |
| wip/w4-103110-final-tests | c95a435f7fa26680b170cd513524086c7064af4d | Author checkpoint/proof/evidence; no separate PR |
| wip/w4-103110-gap-tests | 1d7f954f7382d3db8f0f5c9bf3d5088a69c9f658 | Author checkpoint/proof/evidence; no separate PR |
| wip/w4-103110-pointer-test | 51304d1ad96c63370e9cf33447759bab414020e1 | Author checkpoint/proof/evidence; no separate PR |
| wip/w4-103110-proof | 86f81c62f9d6f6c168512fa1d7514b694be96869 | Author checkpoint/proof/evidence; no separate PR |
| wip/w4-103110-public-final-candidate | f4ae328ce43ca766ac1f1358b8d184142edbd4de | Author checkpoint/proof/evidence; no separate PR |
| wip/w4-103110-public-outcomes | 8382d95fcb42eafd2625d3cdf55097fb3a9df616 | Author checkpoint/proof/evidence; no separate PR |
| wip/w4-103110-recovery-fix | 3b580adce1754ac71fdbf0395ee82e8890bd70bf | Author checkpoint/proof/evidence; no separate PR |
| wip/w4-103110-removal-input-test | be7d75dceb96290f32caf9cfc8e11cdc8406c674 | Author checkpoint/proof/evidence; no separate PR |
| wip/w4-103110-removal-tests | 8e2452eb9cbbdb5c6bd56175571ef0b2ae28cc69 | Author checkpoint/proof/evidence; no separate PR |
| wip/w4-103110-run-40673563054 | f459beff55da7d6e398efcca6ebb686ebd01a28f | Author checkpoint/proof/evidence; no separate PR |
| wip/w4-103110-run-40674942254 | a86a2a796566338a5f89d7e3b8d0d5beab00cd01 | Author checkpoint/proof/evidence; no separate PR |
Reverify the current PR/head and the required bld-build full-suite result, perform the owner's final review, and land only under the owner's authorization. The limited author assignment and its nine red/green/reverted-red proofs are complete; do not repeat them as pending. Keep this broader handoff open until the owner's integration and landing work is genuinely complete.
Written 2026-10-28 11:30 UTC. RE-VERIFY https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/pull/743 with gh pr view --json headRefOid,state before any owner action. Latest author observation is OPEN/c4b30ab1d21c4686eabd911e2561b3e8c1b2d037; the shared source PR has not yet been updated by W4.
The current author brief says: "Do NOT merge, enqueue, deploy. Stop when pushed and the targeted tests pass first-attempt. Further verification past that is a failure to follow this brief." "Never change timeouts, iterations or assertions' strength." "Do not run a full local suite; the PR's bld-build check on the GitHub runner is the full-suite gate." These limits supersede broader historical verification instructions below for this author correction. The broader handoff stays open until owner review/full-suite/landing is complete.
Candidate f4ae328ce43ca766ac1f1358b8d184142edbd4de is pushed at https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w4-103110-public-final-candidate. The final 34-case targeted proof and nine product-only reversals are running at https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/actions/runs/40679030155, on a disposable GitHub runner because shared local JVM admission was busy. Every command explicitly uses --local-and-remote; no required PR CI is the debugging mechanism.
F1: directory-removal names contain creator PID/start plus original parent/target identity fingerprints before mkdir. Startup now revisits certificate generation and root removals, temporary history roots and launcher cleanup. It finishes only matching empty removals after their creator exits, preserving live removers, replacements, nonempty targets and unrecognized inputs. F2: 15 existing tests use public recovery/cleanup outcomes; negative corruption inputs and genuine process setup remain. The rename audit also found a root-level temporary last-good pointer; its unfinished file now lives inside its already-owned generation.
Eight real Runtime.halt child scenarios plus one malformed/mismatched-input scenario all have intended assertion-red evidence on c4b30ab1: six directory cases, launcher input, pointer interruption, nested route interruption. The initial candidate register passed 31/32; its alias failure was also reproduced on unchanged c4b30ab1. That older fixture expected completed cleanup while another saved reference remained. Its original success assertion now follows public retirement of that final reference, with additional pending/whole-directory assertions; no process-cleanup product behavior was weakened. A later run was superseded before completion to replace one final positive PID JSON read with a public PID-store view.
Initial native XML, complete assertion stacks and source hashes are preserved at https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w4-103110-evidence/review-evidence/w4-103110. The six-case test proof succeeded but its separate automatic archive push was refused for workflow-file permission; downloaded native evidence was preserved on this author-owned branch. No test was retried. Dedicated source/test reviews are complete and will be included with final native evidence. No test timeout, iteration count or assertion strength changed.
The two historical PID stress timings remain unexplained: 100s FutureTask / 120s watchdog failures, then 63.927s / 80.874s passes, without a matched same-runner before/after cost mechanism. The PR description will retain the reviewer's explicit statement that persisted cleanup retries do not establish a timing fix.
No artifact or production code was published or deployed. The source PR remains unmerged and not queued. This update does not claim the current final proof has passed yet.
| Repository | Branch | Verified remote head | Role |
|---|---|---|---|
| ContainerNursery | wip/w4-103110-evidence | cb3f04ba658806febd88e12196901d7be2919786 | Author checkpoint/proof/evidence; no separate PR |
| ContainerNursery | wip/w4-103110-final-candidate | 59efb46135bf1277b5659f49338a92cb28ed456b | Author checkpoint/proof/evidence; no separate PR |
| ContainerNursery | wip/w4-103110-final-tests | c95a435f7fa26680b170cd513524086c7064af4d | Author checkpoint/proof/evidence; no separate PR |
| ContainerNursery | wip/w4-103110-gap-tests | 1d7f954f7382d3db8f0f5c9bf3d5088a69c9f658 | Author checkpoint/proof/evidence; no separate PR |
| ContainerNursery | wip/w4-103110-pointer-test | 51304d1ad96c63370e9cf33447759bab414020e1 | Author checkpoint/proof/evidence; no separate PR |
| ContainerNursery | wip/w4-103110-proof | 86f81c62f9d6f6c168512fa1d7514b694be96869 | Author checkpoint/proof/evidence; no separate PR |
| ContainerNursery | wip/w4-103110-public-final-candidate | f4ae328ce43ca766ac1f1358b8d184142edbd4de | Author checkpoint/proof/evidence; no separate PR |
| ContainerNursery | wip/w4-103110-public-outcomes | 8382d95fcb42eafd2625d3cdf55097fb3a9df616 | Author checkpoint/proof/evidence; no separate PR |
| ContainerNursery | wip/w4-103110-recovery-fix | 3b580adce1754ac71fdbf0395ee82e8890bd70bf | Author checkpoint/proof/evidence; no separate PR |
| ContainerNursery | wip/w4-103110-removal-input-test | be7d75dceb96290f32caf9cfc8e11cdc8406c674 | Author checkpoint/proof/evidence; no separate PR |
| ContainerNursery | wip/w4-103110-removal-tests | 8e2452eb9cbbdb5c6bd56175571ef0b2ae28cc69 | Author checkpoint/proof/evidence; no separate PR |
| ContainerNursery | wip/w4-103110-run-40673563054 | f459beff55da7d6e398efcca6ebb686ebd01a28f | Author checkpoint/proof/evidence; no separate PR |
| ContainerNursery | wip/w4-103110-run-40674942254 | a86a2a796566338a5f89d7e3b8d0d5beab00cd01 | Author checkpoint/proof/evidence; no separate PR |
Read the terminal native final results; require 34 first-attempt greens and the nine intended product-only assertion reds with matching source inventories. Rebase on latest main, re-check the PR head and OPEN state, then force-with-lease publish the tested source and update the why-first PR description and requested W4 result JSON. Stop at that verified push. The owner retains the full-suite integration gate, final review and landing; do not archive this handoff at author completion.
Written 2026-10-28 10:08:18 UTC. RE-VERIFY https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/pull/743 with gh pr view --json state,headRefOid before owner action. This is a write-time snapshot; exact-lease publication moved the OPEN, unmerged PR from 62a50cb852a5fe9b9165f822f3459448b7cd06b4 to c4b30ab1d21c4686eabd911e2561b3e8c1b2d037.
The author brief says: "Do NOT merge, enqueue, deploy. Stop when pushed and the targeted tests pass first-attempt. Further verification past that is a failure to follow this brief." "Never raise a timeout, cut iterations, or weaken/skip a test." "Do not run a full local suite; the PR's bld-build check on the GitHub runner is the full-suite gate." This limited author correction is DONE. The broader owner review/full-suite/landing remains, so this handoff must stay open and must not be archived merely because the author pushed.
Published source c4b30ab1d21c4686eabd911e2561b3e8c1b2d037; latest-main rebase was unchanged at publication. All source work is committed and pushed; source checkout is clean. The PR description explains the findings, proofs, timing uncertainty and the owner's remaining integration gate.
M1 retains original path/key through PID retirement and declined reservation. A failed or declined release keeps ownership and retry; public tests cover real default-provider launch, successor-token references, replacement preservation and restored-original retry. M2 holds the original open until final removal, isolates the entry, verifies its moved identity and deletes through an isolated directory handle. M3 obtains the other application's keeper from real ancestry and verifies the opaque public group identity; private fields remain negative corruption input only.
Gap search fixed discovery identity recapture after process inspection, the declined-reservation ownership loss, and an introduced legacy-adoption failure when its unmanaged launch directory is absent. Each public behavior has a named assertion-red, first-attempt green and controlled reversed-fix assertion red. The final dedicated test/implementation self-reviews found no further issue.
The two historical stress tests timed out at 100s FutureTask / 120s watchdog before later 63.927s / 80.874s passes. No same-runner before/after measured mechanism establishes a code change that removed the cost. It remains unexplained; no performance fix or pre-existing attribution is claimed.
Final bounded proof: two initial named reds, 22/22 first-attempt greens, then two intended product-only reversed reds; no attempt histories. All 1,989 runtime input files and restored product hashes match the publication source, including the exact tested fixed implementation. Git-preserved final native data.
Earlier controlled reversals provide four intended original-case reds in the 20-case proof, plus the correct final-read reversal. Exclude the final-read handshake failure from the earlier combined reversal. Together with the two final additional reversals there are seven intended controlled reds across these linked proofs, not seven from one run. Final 22-case green includes all those unchanged regressions.
Full evidence and result: native XML, full assertion stacks, source inventories/audits, source snapshot, dedicated review passes, findings, corrected fixture history and requested JSON. No binaries, caches or generated keys are committed. Invalid/cancelled fixture drafts and one unresolved-ref dispatch are explicitly excluded from accepted proof.
All targeted commands use --local-and-remote. The execution-only public Workspace wrapper fixes one attempt/one local test JVM; for expected reds it copies terminal native local XML before stopping a remote wait. It changes no product code, assertions, iterations or test timeouts. A shared-local-slot attempt was not admitted and ran no test JVM. REST quota exhaustion was worked around with git/GraphQL and a proof push trigger, not a required-CI retry. No owned proof, local test JVM or watcher remains running. Required PR CI started by publication is the owner's gate.
Shared source: feature branch, head c4b30ab1d21c4686eabd911e2561b3e8c1b2d037, https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/pull/743, OPEN/unmerged. Every author checkpoint:
| Branch | Verified remote head | State |
|---|---|---|
| wip/w6-083925-deferred-reference-tests | f9b6bafbfda103a567188f82c692c999022a3cbb | checkpoint/proof/evidence; superseded unless final source or final run |
| wip/w6-083925-directory-fix | 08754bac0eb3997d1c469d38ba0a9ee0d2fa67a1 | checkpoint/proof/evidence; superseded unless final source or final run |
| wip/w6-083925-evidence | 40955518489451385df2eb1c13ce781ad8903f71 | checkpoint/proof/evidence; superseded unless final source or final run |
| wip/w6-083925-final-candidate | 99fb48e3da8495730a2e17c5862272f8a95eb390 | checkpoint/proof/evidence; superseded unless final source or final run |
| wip/w6-083925-final-held-directory | 3729a3883aca45bd42a87d09f144d11adbb6f033 | checkpoint/proof/evidence; superseded unless final source or final run |
| wip/w6-083925-final-removal-tests | e0918fa3f2479b5448947fe0b024d372a9ca5218 | checkpoint/proof/evidence; superseded unless final source or final run |
| wip/w6-083925-gap-tests | 84222b94a32ebc0306e7b96ae19307fb8ea67faa | checkpoint/proof/evidence; superseded unless final source or final run |
| wip/w6-083925-green-candidate | 757cf3af1cb6ab70e81767c20f895855506b0d82 | checkpoint/proof/evidence; superseded unless final source or final run |
| wip/w6-083925-isolated-removal-fix | 99fb48e3da8495730a2e17c5862272f8a95eb390 | checkpoint/proof/evidence; superseded unless final source or final run |
| wip/w6-083925-isolated-removal-tests | ccaf42de17c6126eec2524d5298a5cf87f9fbe88 | checkpoint/proof/evidence; superseded unless final source or final run |
| wip/w6-083925-legacy-adoption-tests | 648aa3db8b6c315ae46731f88943f6c415ba1e42 | checkpoint/proof/evidence; superseded unless final source or final run |
| wip/w6-083925-m3 | b1ee479b4d2f798c924faa3a9147ed63f7e40652 | checkpoint/proof/evidence; superseded unless final source or final run |
| wip/w6-083925-proof | dbf0f411f1bee5edd2fa51730ba1f03492b4f022 | checkpoint/proof/evidence; superseded unless final source or final run |
| wip/w6-083925-rebased-additional-tests | 9f125192a56ccb768a721bac9890857de752719d | checkpoint/proof/evidence; superseded unless final source or final run |
| wip/w6-083925-red-tests | 19cbc8cac15329a389a86231815de73d29a4e9df | checkpoint/proof/evidence; superseded unless final source or final run |
| wip/w6-083925-reference-teardown-tests | d3264bc74815bae73e0905c0ce680b8ae5fa2745 | checkpoint/proof/evidence; superseded unless final source or final run |
| wip/w6-083925-reviewed-final-source | c4b30ab1d21c4686eabd911e2561b3e8c1b2d037 | checkpoint/proof/evidence; superseded unless final source or final run |
| wip/w6-083925-run-40667701613 | ef9bdf299eef82e00c316338ce6cfbc0bb304f7f | checkpoint/proof/evidence; superseded unless final source or final run |
| wip/w6-083925-successor-reference-tests | 3b6e66dee34d918f4d96dd7bec108d8b11ec4bc4 | checkpoint/proof/evidence; superseded unless final source or final run |
| wip/w6-083925-token-reference-tests | b4b9a62155ffd1a3500cb9295317acdfed2dc159 | checkpoint/proof/evidence; superseded unless final source or final run |
No runtime artifact was published or deployed. No production route, container, daemon or package changed. Command inventory is source/tests, git, disposable proof execution, read-only source/status reads and handoff/evidence metadata.
Reverify the current PR/head and required bld-build full-suite result, perform the owner's final review and land only under the owner's authorization. Do not repeat the completed limited author verification as pending, and do not archive this broader handoff before that owner work is complete. No further runtime verification follows this author publication.
Written 2026-10-28 09:05:19 UTC. RE-VERIFY https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/pull/743 with gh pr view --json state,headRefOid before owner action. Latest observed OPEN head is 62a50cb852a5fe9b9165f822f3459448b7cd06b4; this author is still correcting review findings and has not pushed the shared PR.
The current author brief says: "Do NOT merge, enqueue, deploy. Stop when pushed and the targeted tests pass first-attempt. Further verification past that is a failure to follow this brief." "Never raise a timeout, cut iterations, or weaken/skip a test." "Do not run a full local suite; the PR's bld-build check on the GitHub runner is the full-suite gate." Every targeted test races local/remote; disposable GitHub runners are authorized for proof. The wider owner work remains open after this limited author assignment; do not archive it until that wider work is done.
M1: original launch key was discarded before PID retirement and re-captured at deferred deletion. New retained ownership carries path/key together; normal and adopted discovery establish the key before deferred binding/replies. M2: final removal previously used parent/name after traversal. A final metadata check alone also has a replacement window; deterministic public tests demonstrate both the after-read and inside-delete orderings. The final candidate isolates the entry in a private same-filesystem directory, verifies the moved key and removes through that held directory. On mismatch/failure it restores without replacing a newly published original-path entry. The original directory stays open through final removal. M3: other keeper tracking now uses real parent ancestry and equal opaque public checker identities; private parsing is negative corruption input only.
Gap search: startup sweep retained only candidate paths before process inspection and captured keys later. New discovery records retain the original key across inspection. Its public regression fails first on the old source. The previous PID stress failures (100s FutureTask and 120s watchdog) followed by 63,927ms/80,874ms passes remain unexplained. No same-runner measured code change establishes a performance fix; none is claimed.
Initial M1/M2 assertion reds: https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/actions/runs/40658921801 . Discovery-gap red: https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/actions/runs/40659244334 . Intermediate candidate had 9 first-attempt greens and 3 product-only reverted assertion reds: https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/actions/runs/40659796777 . This is intermediate, not final evidence. Final-read gap assertion red: https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/actions/runs/40660211565 . Inside-delete gap assertion red: https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/actions/runs/40660560477 . A dispatch using an unresolved local branch name failed before tests and is excluded: https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/actions/runs/40660047529 . Superseded proof https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/actions/runs/40661227795 was cancelled when the original-handle lifetime correction was added; no passing claim rests on it.
The final held-directory candidate is pushed, and its fresh targeted proof is running. Native XML, hashes and full stacks are local at /code/ws/W6/fix-083925 and will be preserved in the evidence branch. Fresh filtered clone is /code/ws/W6/workspace/ContainerNursery. Findings are /tmp/claude-1000/-code/d242821d-e422-4332-8920-7d296dd44591/scratchpad/out/W6-083925-fix-findings.md.
| Repo | Branch | Remote head | PR | State |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| ContainerNursery | wip/w6-083925-directory-fix | 08754bac0eb3997d1c469d38ba0a9ee0d2fa67a1 | no PR | author checkpoint/proof; shared PR unchanged |
| ContainerNursery | wip/w6-083925-final-candidate | 99fb48e3da8495730a2e17c5862272f8a95eb390 | no PR | author checkpoint/proof; shared PR unchanged |
| ContainerNursery | wip/w6-083925-final-held-directory | 3729a3883aca45bd42a87d09f144d11adbb6f033 | no PR | author checkpoint/proof; shared PR unchanged |
| ContainerNursery | wip/w6-083925-final-removal-tests | e0918fa3f2479b5448947fe0b024d372a9ca5218 | no PR | author checkpoint/proof; shared PR unchanged |
| ContainerNursery | wip/w6-083925-gap-tests | 84222b94a32ebc0306e7b96ae19307fb8ea67faa | no PR | author checkpoint/proof; shared PR unchanged |
| ContainerNursery | wip/w6-083925-green-candidate | 757cf3af1cb6ab70e81767c20f895855506b0d82 | no PR | author checkpoint/proof; shared PR unchanged |
| ContainerNursery | wip/w6-083925-isolated-removal-fix | 99fb48e3da8495730a2e17c5862272f8a95eb390 | no PR | author checkpoint/proof; shared PR unchanged |
| ContainerNursery | wip/w6-083925-isolated-removal-tests | ccaf42de17c6126eec2524d5298a5cf87f9fbe88 | no PR | author checkpoint/proof; shared PR unchanged |
| ContainerNursery | wip/w6-083925-m3 | b1ee479b4d2f798c924faa3a9147ed63f7e40652 | no PR | author checkpoint/proof; shared PR unchanged |
| ContainerNursery | wip/w6-083925-proof | 5244cfbb5039634dd93671bb085a420df9193571 | no PR | author checkpoint/proof; shared PR unchanged |
| ContainerNursery | wip/w6-083925-red-tests | 19cbc8cac15329a389a86231815de73d29a4e9df | no PR | author checkpoint/proof; shared PR unchanged |
No runtime artifact, production route, container, daemon or package was deployed or published. Work consists of source/test/proof Git branches and disposable targeted test execution.
Finish final first-attempt targeted green and product-only reverted-red verification, independently review test/implementation changes, rebase on latest main, recheck the shared PR remains OPEN at its incoming head, push with an exact force-with-lease, update the why-first description and author result. Stop there; the owner retains full-suite review/landing. Never merge, enqueue or deploy under this author brief.
Written 2026-10-28 08:05 UTC. RE-VERIFY https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/pull/743 with gh pr view --json state,headRefOid,mergeStateStatus,statusCheckRollup before owner action. All state is a write-time snapshot.
The 2026-10-28 author brief says: "Do NOT merge, enqueue, deploy. Stop when pushed and the targeted tests pass first-attempt. Further verification past that is a failure to follow this brief." "Never raise a timeout, cut iterations, or weaken/skip a test." "Do not run a full local suite; the PR's bld-build check on the GitHub runner is the full-suite gate." Every targeted command uses --local-and-remote; at most one local test JVM on the shared machine. This limited author assignment ends at a verified PR push. The broader original owner review/landing handoff stays open.
The limited W6-070636 author correction is FIXED and published to the OPEN, unmerged PR at https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/commit/62a50cb852a5fe9b9165f822f3459448b7cd06b4. Latest-main rebase left the exact tested head unchanged; the immediate incoming-head check and exact --force-with-lease succeeded. The author stops here; owner full-suite review and landing remain.
M1: an exited Linux claimant retains a process entry and birth but cannot resume cleanup. Signal-claim admission now checks Z/X/x execution state before preserving the reservation. Two public tests create a real crashed cleaner and recover its process or saved group before its Python parent reaps it using waitid(WNOWAIT).
M2: a pathname can name a new directory after the original is renamed. Start captures the original directory key before launcher callbacks and transfers key/path together through normal and failed-start cleanup. Both public replacement scenarios preserve the caller's sentinel, assert the exact refusal and retained ownership, restore the original directory and verify retry.
M3: the audit replaces positive private process-group.identity field parsing in 38 tests with real process ancestry and equal opaque public checker identities. Cleanup, replacement, reparenting, PID reuse, count and scale assertions are retained. The unpublished-child test has its own separate correction: public start rejection proves kill entered before the pending future check. It retains real child/port and exactly-once cleanup assertions.
Four initial assertion reds: https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/actions/runs/40646987496 . Four first-attempt greens: https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/actions/runs/40647704955 . Earlier strengthened-test product-only reversal is 4/4 assertion red: https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/actions/runs/40648368860 . Final reviewed exact-source proof: https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/actions/runs/40651544740 — 45/45 first-attempt greens with no attempt histories, followed by 4/4 intended product-only assertion reds. All five source/build/test/restoration inventories match; only NurseryPidFile.kt and DangerJarFileBackedContainer.kt differ for reversal. Claims 63927ms, storage 80874ms, strengthened unpublished-child 4229ms. Omitted-wait control: https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/actions/runs/40650340904 — intended first-attempt assertion red, all automatic attempts remain red; only the product wait differs and product hashes are restored.
Clean main stress controls: https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/actions/runs/40649336649 — two first-attempt passes, 38242ms claims and 90852ms storage. Inventories match current main 7a53d64bb90ba3f8ec03c2ab9bc743d9c6e92c4a with zero mismatches. Final targeted stress selectors run as separate racing calls; internal callers, 128 rounds, payloads, sizes, iterations, timeouts and resource assertions are unchanged. No performance fix or unrelated/pre-existing attribution is claimed. The previous bundled baseline failed, and diagnostic jcmd attachment invalidated resource counts by starting the Attach Listener; those results remain excluded from passing evidence.
Independent product/test review found no product defect in M1/M2. It found and closed a pre-call entry-handshake gap and setup/teardown cleanup gaps in the crash fixtures. Independent M3 review is clean after explicit correction of three duplicate setup local names found by compilation. Superseded proof https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/actions/runs/40650338025 has 40 first-attempt runtime passes and 3 compile-only failures, not an overall green; it never reached stress/reversal. The canceled preceding proof is excluded too. Complete histories and limitations are in the evidence branch.
| Repository | Branch | Remote head | PR | State |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| ContainerNursery | wip/w6-065126-fix | d832380367625bb6cb266e4cae49d4b7091ba5f9 | no PR | Historical checkpoint preserved |
| ContainerNursery | wip/w6-065126-proof | a3683629a76c0784be190b411c1dcb314a383430 | no PR | Disposable execution harness |
| ContainerNursery | wip/w6-065126-tests | e1adaf4df7a1544773e883ca2a1e08bd48c1d4af | no PR | Historical checkpoint preserved |
| ContainerNursery | wip/w6-070636-evidence | c42ed20fcd7b275313433bbcfba0c42ebd09675b | no PR | Native proof/review/result evidence |
| ContainerNursery | wip/w6-070636-final | 62a50cb852a5fe9b9165f822f3459448b7cd06b4 | https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/pull/743 | Published exact tested source; 45 first-attempt greens; unmerged |
| ContainerNursery | wip/w6-070636-proof | d283955b1de045ab19cc23e6e21e1a1d3b01f205 | no PR | Disposable execution harness |
The previous unpushed strengthened-tests commit was carried into the final candidate under its new commit. The38 uncommitted edits from the previous clone were preserved in the final candidate. No source work remains only in a volatile checkout. Evidence branch includes native XML, full assertion/compilation stacks, source/test inventories, review notes and correction history; no binaries, dependency caches, keys or production files are included.
This author deployed or published no runtime artifact. The command inventory consists of git/source edits, targeted disposable-runner execution, read-only PR/actions checks and handoff/evidence metadata. No production route, container, daemon or artifact coordinate was changed. The source remains unmerged in the open PR.
Reverify the current PR and required full-suite gate, perform the original owner's final review/landing under its authorization. Do not repeat completed author verification as pending. Do not complete/archive this broader handoff until that original work is finished. This author stops after the verified push and releases its claim; no further runtime verification follows publication.
Read native attempt histories: a retry pass is not a first-attempt green. Establish API entry through observable admission state before asserting a future waits. Do not attach jcmd after resource baselining; the Attach Listener itself changes the measured resources. Tests of private saved record corruption may inject opaque damage, but positive ownership assertions should use public process/checker observations.
Written 2026-10-28 06:28 UTC. RE-VERIFY the live pull request https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/pull/743 before owner action. This is a write-time snapshot.
Finish the original owner's full-suite review and landing. The W6-050404 review correction is FIXED and published at https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/commit/fd61f6aade014904f794112cd885554bde63ece8. It fixes rejected-peer reply failures, moves physical directory cleanup outside the shared PID lock, replaces private identity-field parsing, and removes the three whitespace nits.
The author brief says “Do NOT merge, enqueue, deploy. Stop when pushed and the targeted tests pass first-attempt. Further verification past that is a failure to follow this brief.” It also says “Never raise a timeout, cut iterations, or weaken/skip a test” and “Do not run a full local suite; the PR's bld-build check on the GitHub runner is the full-suite gate.” This author assignment is complete at its verified push; the broader handoff remains open for the owner. No runtime verification is started afterward.
Peer-local rejection reply errors are isolated; accepted control behavior remains covered. Directory cleanup publishes a saved per-directory claim in a short PID transaction, performs traversal/deletion outside the lock, and merges current records while retiring only its own claim. The claim follows directory identity through renames, prevents concurrent/reentrant proof publication, survives restarts, and recognizes exited Linux owners even while unreaped.
Original behavior findings have assertion-red, first-attempt green, and product-only reverted-red proofs. Gap search additionally found and corrected directory rename and unreaped-owner behavior, each test-first; callback reentry and failure-release recovery use a different JVM to verify saved claim retirement. Independent test/code review is clean. Native XML, full assertion stacks, source/test hashes, all excluded setup attempts and diagnostic history are saved in the evidence branch.
Final exact-head proof: https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/actions/runs/40642883297 — 10/10 attempt-one passes. Neighbors: https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/actions/runs/40639406856 — 20/20 attempt-one passes. Product-only reversals: https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/actions/runs/40642291075 (peers), https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/actions/runs/40642294465 (directory), https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/actions/runs/40642297818 (rename), and https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/actions/runs/40643430466 (unreaped owner). Hash audits and native XML are in the evidence branch. No automatic retry pass is accepted as proof. The seven recovery iterations remain intact. No timeout or assertion is weakened.
The previous nine-case result had a fixture setup failure followed by retry success and was rejected. An injected incomplete cmdline on a real unrelated process reproduced the correct conservative cleanup refusal before fixture deletion. The final fixtures restrict only /proc enumeration through the existing filesystem dependency, retaining real deletion, raw owner state/birth and PID storage; waitid(WNOWAIT) verifies owner exit23 without reaping. This history remains explicit.
Source and requested result: https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w6-050404-final-candidate and https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w6-050404-evidence . All source checkpoints below are durable; evidence contains no build outputs, JARs or cache files. No deployment or artifact publication occurred in this session.
Reverify the current PR and required full-suite check, perform the owner's final review and landing under its authorization. Do not repeat author verification as though it were pending. Do not complete/archive this broader handoff until the original owner work is actually done. The W6-050404 author claim is released after its final report. No delegates, test processes or watchers remain owned by this author session.
| Branch | Remote head | State |
|---|---|---|
| https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w6-050404-directory-compile-ready | ca1fd6b3b1223531582475aea605ff26b00b8e13 | Historical checkpoint superseded by final source |
| https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w6-050404-directory-fix | f050ed46e0a98bbf9cd61f2a18d24180d4e81eb4 | Historical checkpoint superseded by final source |
| https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w6-050404-directory-gap-tests | 08c10d50f88a8e3a4152515ff1df80b1c61e37c1 | Historical checkpoint superseded by final source |
| https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w6-050404-directory-tests | d0749f7cf4e154f2aaaa3e4da4781f9045799fa1 | Historical checkpoint superseded by final source |
| https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w6-050404-evidence | fb2effc2f194448d373d02ab39bf6c8ca6d39507 | Evidence only |
| https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w6-050404-final-candidate | fd61f6aade014904f794112cd885554bde63ece8 | Final verified source |
| https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w6-050404-inode-fix | 8ccbea828a5f9e47e83a56f3617203518e707148 | Historical checkpoint superseded by final source |
| https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w6-050404-owner-diagnostic-amplifier | a723c5a722094fc9b04fa1ae9e09f55243db9eeb | Historical checkpoint superseded by final source |
| https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w6-050404-owner-diagnostics | 6fe8f3d9b5211cac872011b268832208b5fc31b2 | Historical checkpoint superseded by final source |
| https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w6-050404-owner-proc-fault | 0c8a7447667265d52b6c291d087593e6bcc0708f | Historical checkpoint superseded by final source |
| https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w6-050404-owner-proc-fault-ready | b203ba79e46bf4cba277510985060fda2d4ba9a1 | Historical checkpoint superseded by final source |
| https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w6-050404-peer-fix | dfadc04d68c4012fa03e4ce105711857ca0879c8 | Historical checkpoint superseded by final source |
| https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w6-050404-peer-tests | 5e6c6bad18daa65cd93fb6605b27694254f74633 | Historical checkpoint superseded by final source |
| https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w6-050404-proof | 3994d19b3b14d8322fd1d7014273ebb7884a2029 | Disposable executor only |
| https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w6-050404-public-group-guard | 2825af6d898e4e08309a181cc966601a140fd967 | Historical checkpoint superseded by final source |
| https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w6-050404-recovery-atomic-ready | 6c6224f8660cd711ce4c3bf8ffda4ccb191bb540 | Historical checkpoint superseded by final source |
| https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w6-050404-recovery-compile-ready | 21c24289ca2140465201b832d55b23bdeb8f17bc | Historical checkpoint superseded by final source |
| https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w6-050404-recovery-fixture | 7abe24a214e550f9ef5c9cc5be1e462c1308d78d | Historical checkpoint superseded by final source |
| https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w6-050404-reentry-cross-process | 8f7b8fb02d2ce38fe9e95061d423ae5f9295656c | Historical checkpoint superseded by final source |
| https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w6-050404-reentry-test | 33836841d63e21db942a771d8727728b08adf35d | Historical checkpoint superseded by final source |
| https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w6-050404-rename-test | 0d4c29b18041761a8e40cd85aa8dfabc78db2f90 | Historical checkpoint superseded by final source |
| https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w6-050404-short-peer-fixtures | 48ccc2ed76519106d4b8550134907679b04a3cbc | Historical checkpoint superseded by final source |
| https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w6-050404-unreaped-owner-test | 288103eda64e43cd1874fa98293c95462ddb8e44 | Historical checkpoint superseded by final source |
Written 2026-10-28 04:45 UTC. RE-VERIFY the OPEN PR https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/pull/743 using gh pr view <full-url> --json state,headRefOid,statusCheckRollup before owner action. This is a write-time snapshot.
Finish the owner's full-suite review and landing of the cleanup PR. The limited M1 author correction is FIXED and published; this author has no remaining implementation/verification step. The broader owner work remains open.
The author brief says: “Do NOT merge, enqueue, deploy. Stop when pushed and the targeted tests pass first-attempt. Further verification past that is a failure to follow this brief.” It also says: “Never raise a timeout, cut iterations, or weaken/skip a test.” “Do not run a full local suite; the PR's bld-build check on the GitHub runner is the full-suite gate.” The author stopped at that scope and has released its claim. No runtime verification was started after targeted publication. Complete this handoff only when the broader original owner work is actually finished.
2026-10-28 04:43 UTC — DONE: limited author review correction
Original request: fix M1 on https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/pull/743, prove it test-first with racing local/remote execution, search the neighboring lock-held dependency work, push the verified source and stop. No merge, enqueue or deployment was authorized.
The PR is OPEN and unmerged at https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/commit/6c96d6a3fce6d81b660242dbed2cb000e428b808, freshly verified by the successful PR-description update response. Latest-main rebase made no source change. An immediate OPEN/exact incoming-head check preceded the exact --force-with-lease push, and git ls-remote confirmed its result.
Cleanup now reserves one owner under a brief state lock, runs process stops, waits and directory cleanup outside it, and publishes the exact result under the lock. Committed launcher and stream setup retain an ownership claim while external callers can reach their interruptible waits. Rejected stream callbacks preserve startup, failed cleanup keeps its resources, and late preparation transfers its directory to owned cleanup before releasing it.
The final disposable executor https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/actions/runs/40632565197 proves 20/20 first-attempt greens (seven new/corrected scenarios, thirteen lifecycle neighbors), four intended assertion reds with only the original product restored, and one intended assertion red with only callback admission order reverted. The separate late-directory coverage mutation is assertion-red at https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/actions/runs/40632562646 . Exact source/test/build-input hashes match the pushed head; both executors restored fixed source. No green has a prior failed attempt. Expected red cases retain their automatic runner attempt history; no unchanged job was manually rerun.
One executor setup error and two non-compiling candidate probes ran no test bodies and are explicitly excluded from behavioral proof. The duplicate local-variable error was fixed before the actual callback assertion-red baseline. The original launcher fixture's circular wait and wrong independent-caller expectation were corrected explicitly, retaining its real root/helper and observation-count assertions.
Delegated work at a glance: one gpt-6-luna max invocation performed separate read-only test-comprehensiveness and adversarial-code passes. It found the stream callback ordering issue and two resource coverage gaps; all are addressed and its final review against the published source is clean. That invocation is finished; no delegates are active.
Blockers: none for this completed author assignment. No unnecessary holds. No idle landing gates; landing is prohibited in this assignment. Owner direction captured: no new direction beyond the author brief's test-first, exact-lease and stop-after-push requirements, recorded in this handoff.
The required bld-build full-suite gate and the original owner's broader review/landing work remain with that owner. This session started no full local suite and no runtime verification after targeted publication, merged/enqueued nothing and deployed/published no artifact. All proof jobs and author-owned watchers are terminal. The original handoff stays open for the broader owner work; this author's claim is released.
Evidence and requested result: https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w6-035934-evidence . Requested local result: /tmp/claude-1000/-code/d242821d-e422-4332-8920-7d296dd44591/scratchpad/out/W6-035934-fix-result.json .
Next steps for this author assignment: none — the requested correction is complete.
Lessons: gate the exact dependency phase being reviewed; reject same-thread callbacks before changing lifecycle state; distinguish setup/build failures from actual first-attempt test outcomes and audit raw XML rather than relying on a final green check.
| Repository | Branch | Verified remote head | PR | Contents/state |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| ContainerNursery | fix/hd22-L80-no-orphan-sleep-helpers | 6c96d6a3fce6d81b660242dbed2cb000e428b808 | https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/pull/743 | Exact source verified by 20 first-attempt greens; OPEN and unmerged |
| ContainerNursery | wip/w6-035934-callback-test | 1113eddd32487494db2bdde09a2e757d538e2f0c | no PR | Non-compiling intermediate checkpoint; superseded by verified source |
| ContainerNursery | wip/w6-035934-candidate | 8b97c10f191c5403b61dd5d8370d7ee2a7d660f7 | no PR | Non-compiling intermediate checkpoint; superseded by verified source |
| ContainerNursery | wip/w6-035934-compile-ready | 848d2bc9cafdf62a1923fea1799f91ea963f429e | no PR | Intermediate author checkpoint; superseded by verified source |
| ContainerNursery | wip/w6-035934-evidence | 19b212a25935ce9143ea646066f707e26842628e | no PR | Complete native proof, hash audit, reviews and result; not production source |
| ContainerNursery | wip/w6-035934-final-candidate | 6c96d6a3fce6d81b660242dbed2cb000e428b808 | no PR | Exact source verified by 20 first-attempt greens; OPEN and unmerged |
| ContainerNursery | wip/w6-035934-fixture-correction | 513f16ae8664e1c34b3fed4d5ed8a7d2033f1735 | no PR | Intermediate author checkpoint; superseded by verified source |
| ContainerNursery | wip/w6-035934-gap-tests | e785c7590b28780cc7096cb238b581fb3cf22cb8 | no PR | Test-first checkpoint with intended assertion reds; superseded by verified source |
| ContainerNursery | wip/w6-035934-proof | a9615d97e74c22ab51541d7e6d8e960023e54768 | no PR | Terminal disposable executor; all intended first-attempt verdicts verified |
| ContainerNursery | wip/w6-035934-startup-resource-tests | 3b26edd37e467e536a761809fd5e7cac68af9f4a | no PR | Test-first checkpoint with intended assertion reds; superseded by verified source |
| ContainerNursery | wip/w6-035934-tests | adb110cb1acaa992fdbbf2041a84207b0374af04 | no PR | Test-first checkpoint with intended assertion reds; superseded by verified source |
All source, test-first checkpoints, executor and native proof artifacts are on remote branches. Source, executor and evidence worktrees are clean. No build JAR/cache is committed. This author deployed or published no runtime artifact; only Git branches, PR description and this record changed. No merge, queue or deployment action occurred.
The limited author assignment has no remaining step. The owner's required bld-build full-suite gate, broader fresh review and landing remain pending with that owner. This author did not wait on or rerun required CI after publication. Re-verify live state and read current native proof before owner action.
Gate the exact dependency phase a caller can overlap: a test held at initial identity observation does not prove behavior during physical destroy/wait. Reject same-thread callbacks before changing lifecycle state, while preserving any explicitly different launcher-stop contract. Inspect attempt one in native XML and reject later-pass greens; setup/compile failures are separate from executed behavioral assertions. Keep child fixture compilation cached outside timed test bodies.
Current author F1 correction is FIXED. Re-verify live PR state before any owner action: https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/pull/743 . Description update freshly confirmed it OPEN at https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/commit/347d4113b222350323479dbcec5b195c05221ea0 . Latest-main rebase used 7a53d64bb90ba3f8ec03c2ab9bc743d9c6e92c4a and made no source changes; an exact incoming-head lease protected the push.
The author brief says: “Do NOT merge, enqueue, deploy. Stop when pushed and the targeted tests pass first-attempt. Further verification past that is a failure to follow this brief.” “Never raise timeouts or cut iterations.” The PR's required bld-build remains the owner's full-suite gate. No further runtime verification was started after the accepted proof. Broader owner review/full-suite/landing remains separate and this handoff stays open.
Author result FIXED, 2026-10-28. The requested process-death coverage is published at https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/commit/347d4113b222350323479dbcec5b195c05221ea0 in the OPEN PR https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/pull/743 . Three real -Xmx128m renewal children halt after certificate publication, pair publication, or completion before configuration commit. Each test checks the unchanged public route, actual SNI TLS and aggregate storage cleanup through two restarts, without reading/seeding private recovery files. Product source and the existing matrix are unchanged.
Native proof https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/actions/runs/40612424785 has all three new cases assertion-red 3/3 when only generation cleanup is removed, followed by four first-attempt greens with the restored product (three new tests plus existing matrix), no retries. All source/test hashes match. Two runner setup attempts executed zero tests and are excluded. No timeout or iteration was changed. Same-class gap search and independent coverage/code review found no remaining findings. Evidence: https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w1-review25-evidence-20261028 .
The exact-head lease-protected push and description update are complete. No merge, enqueue, deploy or full suite was performed. All author proof jobs, watchers and delegated review are terminal; no active goal was created. This completes the limited author assignment. The original owner's broader full-suite/review/landing work remains open, so the handoff is kept open and the completed author's claim is released. Next author steps: none.
Written 2026-10-27 23:05 UTC. RE-VERIFY https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/pull/743 using gh pr view <full-url> --json state,headRefOid,statusCheckRollup. The author correction is FIXED and published. The owner's broader full-suite/review/landing work is separate and remains pending.
The current author brief says: "Do NOT merge, enqueue, deploy. Stop when pushed and the targeted tests pass first-attempt. Further verification past that is a failure to follow this brief." "Never raise a timeout, cut iterations, or weaken/skip a test." "Do not run a full local suite; the PR's bld-build check on the GitHub runner is the full-suite gate." The author stopped at that scope. No further runtime verification was started after accepted proof.
PR https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/pull/743 is verified OPEN at https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/commit/da380c3dcd6a0c333958c5bc0e53d685d06d9354 by the successful description update response. Latest-main merge-preserving rebase used https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/commit/89f3685f2587877ee266d5ff5e10996d52040020 . A fresh OPEN/exact incoming-head check immediately preceded the shared push, protected by --force-with-lease against 5b672244e7e600c26d840b82872dc1f79f197cee. git ls-remote confirmed the published shared head. Source worktree is clean.
All four requested failures still failed on the incoming head: two exact 30-second timeout locations and two launcher-exit assertions. None was fixed by the previous round. Reproduction is https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/actions/runs/40595320050 .
The suggested product-regression cause is refuted. Main's accepted-connection readiness change landed after the PR-only fixtures were written. Twenty-three fixtures immediately closed every accepted probe, and four bound without accepting. Main and PR readiness functions are identical after normalizing their clock method. Identical public startup controls against main (https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/actions/runs/40595662602) and PR product (https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/actions/runs/40595666294) each pass on the first attempt: closed probes remain unready; held accepted probes complete startup. The nursery ManualClock is not passed through its provider to these JARs, refuting the initial clock hypothesis as well.
Only 27 embedded Java fixture bodies changed this round. They retain accepted connections until nursery EOF; four formerly bound-only fixtures accept before their unchanged sleep. Every byte outside the Java strings, including all original assertions, expected values, waits, counts and timeouts, remains unchanged. Product source, build rules and scripts remain unchanged. The complete original tests now reach and pass their disposal/recovery assertions. README already states the correct readiness contract.
Final native proof https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/actions/runs/40596835960 has 27/27 first-attempt GREEN, then 27/27 expected RED when only the original fixtures are restored. No attempt history exists. The four first greens are L205 2413ms, active-cleanup-read-failure 2439ms, L204 3129ms, temp-sweep-read-failure 2927ms. Each reversal restores its original error and location. The 23 same-class neighbors were independently baseline red at https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/actions/runs/40595997482 and https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/actions/runs/40596001376 . Digest audit matches all final source/test hashes to the published source and all reversed tests to the incoming source, with product bytes identical across both phases.
Separate test and code reviews are complete; the only finding was indentation in 15 Java snippets, corrected and independently audited with no token or line-count changes. An earlier pre-formatting verifier was canceled and has no XML; it is excluded from final proof. No unchanged CI job was requeued. Every targeted command raced local/remote on disposable GitHub runners, with one attempt and one local test JVM each; no local test JVM was started on the shared machine. All author verification jobs/watchers are terminal.
| Branch | Remote head | Contents/state |
|---|---|---|
| https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/fix/hd22-L80-no-orphan-sleep-helpers | da380c3dcd6a0c333958c5bc0e53d685d06d9354 | Shared published source; author verification complete; owner gate remains |
| https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w1-review20-runner-20261027-2233 | a0d0e0edab5e7f308e2300c049535f3e2bacedf9 | Original unchanged four/23 baseline executor; terminal |
| https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w1-review20-controls-20261027-2235 | 6dcda43116de75c15bf9fe2cb88b96878b2c4ae4 | Main/head startup controls; four first-attempt green; terminal |
| https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w1-review20-candidate-20261027-2238 | da380c3dcd6a0c333958c5bc0e53d685d06d9354 | Exact reviewed source published on the shared PR |
| https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w1-review20-verify-20261027-2238 | e10b8a7c9796fcfb448bd7218d25f8af3315069a | Final executor; 27 green then 27 original-fixture reds; terminal |
| https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w1-review20-evidence-20261027-2239 | 3e9384d19eff7432eca43f1eaf924b2c1416de5f | Native XML/logs/hashes/reviews/final result and description; durable evidence |
Evidence: https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w1-review20-evidence-20261027-2239/review20 . The final native XML, complete stacks and commands, digest/preservation audits, separate reviews, requested result JSON and updated PR description are all there. No runtime binaries, JARs, classes or dependency caches are committed. Local requested outputs are scratchpad/out/W1-222820-fix-findings.md and W1-222820-fix-result.json.
Re-verify live head and use the owner's required full-suite/review/landing process. The PR's bld-build is the full-suite gate; this author deliberately did not wait for or claim its final verdict. Do not turn the author's targeted FIXED result into a full-suite or merge verdict. The author brief prohibits merge, queue action and deployment. Keep this broader handoff open for the separate owner scope, and release the completed author's claim.
No code was deployed or artifact published by this continuation: its command inventory is Git/source publication, disposable test execution, read-only APIs, PR metadata, evidence and handoff metadata. No production server restart, Maven publication, PR close, merge or queue action occurred.
Written 2026-10-27 22:24 UTC. RE-VERIFY the live state/head and full-suite gate on https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/pull/743 before owner action. Current author scope is FIXED and stops at targeted publication; broader owner review/landing remains.
The author brief says: "Do NOT merge, enqueue, deploy. Stop when pushed and the targeted tests pass first-attempt. Further verification past that is a failure to follow this brief." "Never raise timeouts or cut iterations." "Do not run a full local suite; the PR's bld-build check on the GitHub runner is the full-suite gate." Those instructions supersede contrary historical instructions below for this author continuation. No further runtime verification was started after the accepted final proof.
Both requested findings are fixed and published at https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/commit/5b672244e7e600c26d840b82872dc1f79f197cee . The REST description update freshly verifies the PR OPEN at that head. Latest-main merge-preserving rebase used https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/commit/89f3685f2587877ee266d5ff5e10996d52040020 . A fresh OPEN/exact-head check and an exact --force-with-lease protected publication; git ls-remote confirmed the shared head.
F1: cleanup reserves ownership before identity/descendant observation outside the monitor, retains real descendant handles before stopping the parent, and preserves an unresolved initial observation across late startup failure. A stop requested inside the launcher finishes after its enclosing monitor is released. Both cleanup methods and both initial observation orderings have real-parent/real-child regressions. Five same-class gaps are covered: handle without PID support, thrown cleanup PID observation, independent start/stop while cleanup binding is held, a stopped launcher, and both identity methods unsupported through late startup failure. An unrelated real process is preserved.
F2: the history test reads no private owner.json/closed state. It checks the complete public exception, retained directory and recovery by a new public constructor. Its test and production history hashes match the isolated old-listing-catch assertion red/current-product first green proof.
Final current-source proof https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/actions/runs/40591952674 has sixteen first-attempt greens, then nineteen intended assertion reds when only DangerJarFileBackedContainer.kt is restored to incoming product. Each of the four required cases is red 3/3. The corrected callback fixture is separately assertion-red when only the cleanup reservation guard is removed. Every targeted command races local/remote; the public Workspace factory sets one attempt and one local test JVM. Native XML has no attempt history. Eighteen selected source hashes match the published candidate, all reversed tests/history are unchanged, and the runner differs only in its three disposable helper/workflow files.
The first candidate register was 14/15 because an existing callback test fired its filesystem hook after outer termination and asserted the parent was still alive. Incoming product reproduces the same failure at https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/actions/runs/40591477347 . Its hook now runs at the supplied public Process.isAlive boundary before signals, preserving every wait and all seven assertions. The first candidate's both-unsupported-methods gap was independently assertion-red at https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/actions/runs/40591001502 before its correction. One earlier disposable-runner indentation error ran zero tests and is excluded. No unchanged CI job was requeued.
| Branch | Remote head SHA | Contents/state |
|---|---|---|
| https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/fix/hd22-L80-no-orphan-sleep-helpers | 5b672244e7e600c26d840b82872dc1f79f197cee | Shared PR source; verified and description updated |
| https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w1-review19-tests-20261027-2142 | 61059933b7502f7be5565bf62b349fc74abd34eb | Initial eight real-tree tests before product changes; superseded by final source |
| https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w1-review19-candidate-20261027-2154 | 5b672244e7e600c26d840b82872dc1f79f197cee | Exact source now published on shared PR |
| https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w1-review19-runner-20261027-2144 | e14cfb859605cdd6791c7b428eea259fc0d8b9ea | Disposable executor only; final run terminal/successful; do not merge its workflow/helper |
| https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w1-review19-evidence-20261027-2155 | c64a8a10845eb2b5f4921f86d7713f6aabe7a071 | Native XML/logs/hashes/reviews/result and prior/final descriptions |
Native proof, complete stacks, source hashes, test/code review, callback preservation audit and requested result JSON are at https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w1-review19-evidence-20261027-2155/review19 . Requested local deliverables are scratchpad/out/W1-213917-fix-findings.md and W1-213917-fix-result.json. The source checkout is clean at the published candidate. No build outputs, jars, dependency caches or test artifacts are in the PR diff.
Re-verify PR state and use the owner's required full-suite/review/landing process on the new head. The author assignment deliberately ends at the requested targeted publication and makes no full-suite verdict or merge/deploy decision. This broader handoff remains open for that separate owner work; the completed author claim is released. All author proof jobs/watchers are terminal. No local test JVM, production deployment/restart, Maven package publication, queue action, merge or PR close was performed by this continuation.
Written 2026-10-27 22:10 UTC. RE-VERIFY PR state/head with gh pr view https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/pull/743 --json state,headRefOid,statusCheckRollup. This is a current author continuation; the historical archived snapshot below was stale at pickup. The handoff has been reopened.
The 2026-10-27 author brief says: "Do NOT merge, enqueue, deploy. Stop when pushed and the targeted tests pass first-attempt. Further verification past that is a failure to follow this brief." "Never raise timeouts or cut iterations." "Do not run a full local suite; the PR's bld-build check on the GitHub runner is the full-suite gate." Every targeted command races local/remote; this pass uses disposable GitHub runners with one attempt and one local JVM. These statements govern this author continuation over historical instructions.
Live PR https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/pull/743 remains OPEN at 9e11d347db17cc83af1f3ca4a490af94a0572a39. Two review findings are being fixed: cleanup must preserve real descendants while initial PID/handle binding is held; history tests must assert public recovery without reading private owner JSON. Main remains 89f3685f2587877ee266d5ff5e10996d52040020. No shared PR push yet.
Observed assertion-red proofs cover the four PID/handle x kill/shutdown cases and five additional ownership cases: handle without PID support, failed cleanup observation, cleanup reservation/lock availability, stopped launcher, and both methods unsupported through late startup failure. The history rewrite has an old-listing-catch assertion red and current-product first green. First candidate yielded fourteen greens and one unchanged callback-fixture failure. The incoming product reproduces that fixture failure as well; its hook was after outer termination, so it now observes the public Process.isAlive callback before signalling, with all seven assertions and all waits unchanged.
Current candidate reserves cleanup before out-of-lock identity/descendant observation, preserves uncertainty until initial observation actually publishes, and completes a stopped launch outside its enclosing monitor. Final current-source execution is https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/actions/runs/40591952674. It must show corrected callback guard-only red, sixteen first greens and nineteen product-only reverted assertion reds (the required four cases red 3/3). That result is pending; do not infer it from source review.
| Branch | Verified remote SHA | State |
|---|---|---|
| https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w1-review19-tests-20261027-2142 | 61059933b7502f7be5565bf62b349fc74abd34eb | Test/runner/evidence checkpoint; do not merge executor or evidence files |
| https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w1-review19-candidate-20261027-2154 | 5b672244e7e600c26d840b82872dc1f79f197cee | Candidate source, awaiting final targeted proof |
| https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w1-review19-runner-20261027-2144 | e14cfb859605cdd6791c7b428eea259fc0d8b9ea | Test/runner/evidence checkpoint; do not merge executor or evidence files |
| https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w1-review19-evidence-20261027-2155 | aa149e2020c324cd1233c1ff2dc2c0e0fca7eb18 | Test/runner/evidence checkpoint; do not merge executor or evidence files |
Source/test review, native XML/logs/full stacks, invocation hashes, invalid-runner exclusion and the earlier PR description are in the current evidence branch's review19/ directory. Exact local deliverables are scratchpad/out/W1-213917-fix-findings.md and W1-213917-fix-result.json (the result is not written until terminal). One runner indentation error ran zero test bodies and is excluded; no unchanged CI job was requeued.
Next author steps: finish that bounded targeted execution, inspect native first attempts and product-only reversals, rebase on latest main, recheck OPEN/exact head and publish with exact lease, update description/evidence and result, then stop. The original owner's full-suite/review/landing work remains separate. No production deployment, artifact publication, restart, queue action or merge has been performed by this continuation.
Written 2026-10-27 18:55 UTC. RE-VERIFY the live head/state and full-suite gate on https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/pull/743 before owner action. Author scope is complete; broader owner landing gates remain.
2026-10-27 author brief: "Do NOT merge, enqueue, deploy. Stop when pushed and the targeted tests pass first-attempt. Further verification past that is a failure to follow this brief." "Keep all existing assertions, waits, counts and timeouts unchanged." Every targeted test races local/remote; one local test JVM/one attempt through the public Workspace wrapper. The shared slot was busy, so all proofs used authorized disposable GitHub runners. The PR's bld-build is the full-suite gate; no full local suite or required-CI retry was run. These instructions replace contradictory historical instructions below.
Both required review findings are fixed and published at https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/commit/435e9c733e28984efdf54ab82ca5904eca2a9d71. PR was OPEN at that head in the successful18:53 REST metadata update. Final main is89f3685f2587877ee266d5ff5e10996d52040020; merge-preserving rebase completed. Exact live-head lease protected the shared push. The description is updated with current proof and gap results. No final full-suite verdict is claimed or further qualification run started.
A1: kernel peer credentials identify callers, and managed ancestry is rejected at socket acceptance. Active owner changes require the current nursery PID. After legitimate release an external successor nursery can claim. Three public real-JAR scenarios cover descendant CLAIM, RELEASE and CLAIM after release; every command receives a keeper acknowledgement before the lifecycle assertion. Corrected old-product proof3/3 assertion red: https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/actions/runs/40560570155. Fixed6/6 first green (three new regressions plus ordinary nursery death, legitimate adoption and fragmented requests), then all3 intended reds after reverting only JarProcessGroup.kt: https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/actions/runs/40561713159. Native XML has no attempt history.
A2: each settled token keeps weak filesystem/path identity until a readable snapshot confirms absence. Completed-release write errors reconcile immediately without replacing the original error; a retained unsuccessful claim remains eligible for reconciliation when later cleanup removal commits before close reports failure. Two public real-process tests each finish9x2048 operations and preserve the1MiB heap-growth bound. Baseline reds grow1921416/1941952 bytes: https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/actions/runs/40560050379 (only its two memory results are valid; initial long-socket owner fixtures failed setup and are excluded). Fixed6/6 first green (two memory regressions plus acquisition-close, release-write, other-store and unreadable-state controls), then two heap assertion reds after reverting only NurseryPidFile.kt with growth1976000/1922184 bytes: https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/actions/runs/40561864356. No attempt history.
Persisted live-claim exclusion remains2/2 first green: https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/actions/runs/40562174932. These public controls hold a real signal pending while rejecting successor registration, including during another child's cleanup. Total14 distinct first-attempt greens and5 intended product-only reverted reds. Product digests prove each revert changes only its named product file, and publication product bytes match the measured fixed sources. All existing tests, assertions, waits, counts and timeouts are untouched.
The same-class gap search added released-descendant CLAIM and retained-claim cleanup regressions before their product fixes. Separate test and code review passes checked public API coverage, real process collection, unrelated survivors, exact error/close ordering, weak storage identity, persisted exclusion, readable recovery and native-command ownership. No further concrete defect found in touched paths. README already states the repaired lifecycle contracts.
| Repo | Branch | Remote head | PR | Contents/state |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| ContainerNursery | https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/fix/hd22-L80-no-orphan-sleep-helpers | 435e9c733e28984efdf54ab82ca5904eca2a9d71 | https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/pull/743 | Shared final source; tested and description updated |
| ContainerNursery | https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w1-review13-tests-20261027-1821 | 2d5b905d5fe3dc0cdb4d439b73103386ab4d8792 | No PR | Five tests before product fixes; corrected owner fixtures |
| ContainerNursery | https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w1-review13-candidate-20261027-1821 | 435e9c733e28984efdf54ab82ca5904eca2a9d71 | No PR | Same fixed source as shared PR |
| ContainerNursery | https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w1-review13-runner-20261027-1821 | 8580ab2a4db4194608af5019c696cde04c2a8902 | No PR | Disposable bounded workflows/helper; all proof jobs terminal; do not merge executor files |
| ContainerNursery | https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w1-review13-evidence-20261027-1821 | 9c5548c30294d33392b6fb1724727a06a273a6d0 | No PR | Native red/green/revert XML, logs/stacks, hashes, findings, result and prior/final descriptions |
Requested deliverables are W1-182107-fix-findings.md and W1-182107-fix-result.json in the supplied task scratchpad/out, also mirrored as review13/findings.md and review13/result.json on the evidence branch. Initial invalid owner fixtures are preserved and clearly excluded. The fresh source checkout is /code/ws/W1/workspace/ContainerNursery-review13 and is clean. Runtime binaries/classes/caches/build outputs are excluded; pinned executor sources are preserved. All author proof jobs and watchers are terminal, and no local test JVM was started.
Tool note: this host's gh pr edit requests retired GraphQL projectCards and fails with the Projects(classic) deprecation message. Exact description was successfully updated through the REST pull-request PATCH endpoint using a JSON input file. Update gh for a durable tool correction. The task prohibits merge/enqueue, so the challenge-record CLI that automatically merges was not invoked; full failure and workaround are preserved in findings.
Use the latest PR full-suite result, fresh owner review and landing decision under the owner's scope. This author assignment is FIXED and stops at requested targeted publication; it grants no merge, queue or deployment authority. Historical drain attribution and separately tracked failures retain their prior classification; no new attribution is claimed. Keep this broader handoff open for owner work.
No deployed/published code from this continuation: command inventory contains git, test/client verification, read-only API access, PR metadata and handoff metadata. No merge, enqueue, production deployment, restart or Maven publication command ran.
Written2026-10-27 17:55 UTC. RE-VERIFY PR/check state before continuing.
The assigned bootstrap/P1/P2 review findings are complete and pushed to https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/pull/743 at https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/commit/da1c78ccd47367430172c92f5378c14b694cf011. The PR is OPEN. The final snapshot has bld-build and bld-build-release IN_PROGRESS. The author stops here per the brief; no full-suite verdict is claimed.
Bootstrap is independent of PR composition: scripts/build.bash, scripts/test.bash and build.kts are unchanged from current main89f3685f2; current-main script --help exits0. The previous failure was downloading compiler dependencies before any source/buildscript/test read. The failed fresh WIP branch had no compiler cache, while the prior successful branch retained a branch-scoped cache. The current-base run reused that cache, bootstrapped main, then passed all five P1 cases first attempt. No product bootstrap change or older-main fallback was needed.
P1 passed5/5 first attempts in https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/actions/runs/40551991204 and was pushedfbed45f22 before P2. Assertions/waits/counts are unchanged. P2 then completed the corrected executor proof in https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/actions/runs/40553011137: actual ARM/root guard passes; old regular-pointer assertion fails at HeldDirectoryFileReader with open-root errno22; fixed4/4 first attempts pass (ARM pointer, linked pointer, actual ARM/root guard and native Intel control); reverting only reader bytes restores the same assertion-red set. Native XML has no attempt-history. Only then was the candidate cherry-picked, latest-main rebased, source-digest checked and pushed with exact live-head lease. No further qualification run was started.
Mechanism: the reader used Intel O_DIRECTORY/O_NOFOLLOW bits on ARM. On ARM, the parent flag included O_DIRECT and root open returned errno22, so correct cleanup could not remove an unreferenced generation. The correction chooses ARM/Intel native bits for parent and leaf opens while retaining descriptor ownership/cleanup. Existing public tests already preceded the fix. Reproduction commands and full XML/stacks/digests are on the evidence and runner branches below.
Separate source/test review found no further defect. Only HeldDirectoryFileReader has numeric native open flags; Python helpers use symbolic constants. Parent replacement between pointer metadata and native open is explicitly not directly tested; source checks the held parent fileKey and no defect was demonstrated there. That preservation scenario would also pass with the old ARM open failure and does not discriminate this ABI bug. Unsupported architectures preserve recovery generations as documented; no new platform support is claimed.
Retain the current full-suite/review/landing gates under the owner's brief. Do not merge, enqueue or deploy based on this author report. P3 drain comparison remains pre-existing-or-unattributed outside this review-fix pass: historical head2/60 versus main0/20 cannot establish cause. Its prepared main60 control is unrun. The original handoff stays open for broader owner work; only this author assignment is DONE.
| Repo | Branch | Remote head | PR | Contents/state |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| ContainerNursery | https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/fix/hd22-L80-no-orphan-sleep-helpers | da1c78ccd47367430172c92f5378c14b694cf011 | https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/pull/743 | P1/P2 verified and pushed; final full suite in progress |
| ContainerNursery | https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w1-review10-runner-20261027-1642 | 0153d44d93b45b0bbc764d77909406cc1c6bc1ba | No PR | Corrected execution-only bootstrap/P1/P2 controls; both jobs succeeded; old product reader is deliberate phase baseline |
| ContainerNursery | https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w1-review11-evidence-20261027-1730 | 248227c175df16fb87465b8d530590a32a2c1b12 | No PR | All current source/test reviews, main control, P1/P2 native XML/stacks/digests, requested FIXED JSON and final report; prior evidence retained |
No deployed/published code from this continuation. No merge, queue entry, deploy, restart or Maven publication command ran. The source/runner/evidence worktrees are clean; no author local test JVM or raw-run watcher remains active. Runtime binaries/classes/caches are deliberately excluded; exact pinned reconstruction inputs stay on the runner branch. Requested result is W1-173025-fix-result.json and findings W1-173025-fix-findings.md in the task scratchpad, both mirrored remotely in review11.
Written2026-10-27 17:42 UTC. RE-VERIFY live state before resuming.
The current author brief asks for bootstrap diagnosis, P1 publication, then P2 ARM assertion-red/first-green/product-only-revert-red and publication; P3 is optional and may remain pre-existing-or-unattributed. Do not merge/enqueue/deploy; stop after targeted first-attempt verification and source pushes. No full local suite; GitHub bld-build is the complete-suite gate. Every targeted command races local and remote; no unchanged CI retries.
P1 is DONE/PUSHED at https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/commit/fbed45f22ef0fdf0e2a9c65144830d78d57306dc on current main89f3685f2. https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/pull/743 remains open. Runner https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/actions/runs/40551991204 supplied5/5 native first-attempt passes, no attempt history. Its main bootstrap control also exits0 with identical main/PR script digest. The earlier rebased run failed downloading CLI artifacts before reading any source/buildscript/tests; it was outside PR composition. Original successful WIP branch retains branch-scoped Actions compiler cache; the failed fresh WIP branch had no such cache. No product bootstrap patch or old-main fallback was needed.
P2 is RUNNING at https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/actions/runs/40553011137 on reviewed executor0153d44d93b45b0bbc764d77909406cc1c6bc1ba. It will require actual ARM/root guard, existing public old-reader assertion red reaching HeldDirectoryFileReader, four first-attempt fixed passes including native Intel control, and identical product-only reverted red set. Do not adopt or push the candidate without those artifacts. Current source still has the old reader. Corrected candidate remains0a7e6dcfdbbf7c53d8bc3d1c43739ff246d70696. Separate test/code review found no defect in the five fixture corrections or the ARM/Intel flags. Same-class search found only one numeric native open/openat site; Python helpers use symbolic constants. Parent replacement between metadata and native open is an explicit untested timing; source checks the held directory fileKey and no defect was demonstrated there. Unknown Linux architectures preserve generations as documented; no expanded platform claim.
P3 remains OUTSIDE THIS PASS, pre-existing-or-unattributed. Historical head2/60/main0/20 is not attribution. Prepared main60 remains unrun. Owner retains broader review/full-suite/landing. The original handoff is therefore still open.
| Repo | Branch | Remote head | PR | Contents/state |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| ContainerNursery | https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/fix/hd22-L80-no-orphan-sleep-helpers | fbed45f22ef0fdf0e2a9c65144830d78d57306dc | https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/pull/743 | P1 current-base first green, pushed; P2 unadopted |
| ContainerNursery | https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w1-review10-runner-20261027-1642 | 0153d44d93b45b0bbc764d77909406cc1c6bc1ba | No PR | P1/P2 source + execution-only controls; P1 green, P2 running |
| ContainerNursery | https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w1-review11-evidence-20261027-1730 | 8fd4380d1620ff1460e5e2d6b8c46b8c47239ebe | No PR | Current plan/findings/reviews/main control/P1 XML and logs; prior evidence is parent |
No code was merged, queued, deployed, restarted or published as an artifact. Binary runtimes and compiled caches are deliberately excluded; exact pinned reconstruction inputs remain on the runner branch. No author local test JVM was started on the shared machine. The only active author execution is the bounded P2 runner and read-only bounded raw-Actions watcher. Source and evidence are checkpointed remotely; the source checkout is clean.
Written: 2026-10-27 16:57 UTC.
RE-VERIFY: Recheck https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/pull/743 with gh pr view --json headRefOid,state. Shared PR is still ae3e0c641; no new product or fixture changes have been pushed to it in this continuation.
The shared local slot stayed occupied beyond this author's admission window. Cancelled only the author's never-admitted controller (zero tests/no owned local JVM), restored its ignored launcher and removed the loader link. All authorized targeted commands now run on a disposable GitHub runner, still scripts/test.bash --local-and-remote and a public Workspace wrapper forcing one attempt/one local test JVM. No remote-only run, full local suite, product test change, timeout increase, merge, queue entry or deploy.
P1 current runner: https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/actions/runs/40544896022 at375efaab6a8acbe11ed5133d08ab11550fe727c9. It has reached the targeted race step. No native XML/test verdict exists yet. Earlier WIP invocations were cancelled after a main advance, or failed in metadata setup before any test command (missing git, then checkout-owner mismatch). Full stacks and exact URLs are preserved in the review10 evidence branch. No required PR CI was requeued.
Main advanced to9905b30a4 while preparing the runner. The shared source candidate is rebased at60108a183a61f2b0d48d411ef99d8beacd2331ba, and all product/test files match the running WIP head. WIP-only workflow/executor files are the sole differences. P1 must pass5/5 first before publishing this candidate to the shared PR, with fresh head/state and an explicit lease.
P2 next: reviewed portable corrected ARM executor. Runtime inputs have pinned URLs/SHA256, actual ARM/root guard, native Intel positive control, old-product named assertion red reaching HeldDirectoryFileReader, fixed4/4 first green and product-only reverted identical red set. Only then cherry-pick0a7e6dcfd to source PR and publish. Independent read-only review found no byte/shim/classifier/gate defect. Freshness/cleanup concerns are addressed in the latest WIP executor; no redundant P1 re-execution is needed since each job is fresh and controls/tests are unchanged.
P3 next: main changed, so run a fresh60 scenarios on current main; do not combine earlier main20 with newer40 across heads. The main60 WIP control is prepared and pushed, NOT dispatched. Original scenario assertions, four callers,180-second wrapper and 30-second per-scenario limits retained. Historical head2/60 and main0/20 remain historical, not a fresh attribution.
ae3e0c64168678d76be69f9caf3c759d046faa5e refs/heads/fix/hd22-L80-no-orphan-sleep-helpers
46d9200a5a2fe3b7968c018482baabb1dd55954c refs/heads/wip/w1-review10-evidence-20261027-1600
568128c3e018903668ec37779c4560dafc8f4148 refs/heads/wip/w1-review10-main-runner-20261027-1650
eabc6fafa3d286c16545139d2467d692baaa05b4 refs/heads/wip/w1-review10-runner-20261027-1642
Branches:
No deployed/published code from this continuation. Runtime binaries and compiled helper classes remain deliberately excluded; pinned reconstruction sources are on the runner/evidence branches.
The dated author brief below remains authoritative: P1 then P2 then P3; first-attempt gates before shared pushes; force-with-lease after current-main rebase; do NOT merge/enqueue/deploy; stop after requested targeted verification. Reservation/adoption/HTTPS failures are excluded from this PR and recorded separately. Reservation has no main attribution and must not be called pre-existing without that evidence. The current PR description is still the previous author's snapshot and must be refreshed when P1 is published.
Written: 2026-10-27 16:10 UTC.
RE-VERIFY: This is a write-time snapshot. Recheck https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/pull/743 with gh pr view --json headRefOid,state before shared-branch changes. This continuation has executed zero targeted tests so far; no fresh green is claimed.
These supersede the older priority order, normal-push instruction and256-case instruction in the historical snapshot below:
Fresh clone at /code/ws/W1/workspace/ContainerNursery. Source-reviewed test-only fixture cherry-pick is local becf7a1659d2d5a3cdcf495015bcf971bddea774; its source is already preserved in the linked original84c356966 commit. Shared PR remains ae3e0c64168678d76be69f9caf3c759d046faa5e. One bounded queued job runs P1, first-pass gate and live-head-checked push, then old-executor guard, corrected old-reader assertion-red, fixed four-case first green, product-only reverted red and push, then forty additional original main drain scenarios. It retains the shared local slot only for those sequential steps. No local test has started.
Static source/test review and required documentation are recorded in the new evidence branch. The corrected runtime was reconstructed with the exact pinned inputs in review9/ARM-SETUP.md. Only a copied ELF interpreter is changed; original JVM and product dependencies remain intact. Guard and native control are execution-only test scripts, removed before publication. Existing public pointer regressions are already in the shared head before the product correction.
The current five-fixture patch preserves every assertion, latch, wait and count. It changes the startup and pin-release hooks to actual list/delete calls and gives two wrappers DirectoryFileSystem capability. Same-class native-flag search found only HeldDirectoryFileReader; Python code uses platform constants. No additional concrete product defect was found by source/test review. No runtime verdict is inferred from that review.
| Repo | Branch | Remote head SHA | PR | Contents | State |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ContainerNursery | https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w1-review10-evidence-20261027-1600 | 8fef8048360ddb7f00fc361199a6e6293e7ea680 | No PR | Prior evidence as parent plus review10 plan, runner, Linux/QEMU source references and source/test review | Pushed; execution pending |
Older remote candidates and the shared PR are retained in the historical table below. No production code was deployed or artifact published by this continuation; its command inventory is git, read-only documentation/CI, local runtime preparation and handoff metadata. Binaries/caches/compiled helper classes are deliberately excluded from the evidence branch; pinned reconstruction instructions are retained.
Finish P1 and P2 first, respecting first-attempt gates; complete main to the requested matched60 scenarios; update the PR description with actual results and the separate-flake evidence table. The owner retains review/full-suite/landing work. Do not follow the historical256-case or reservation-fix steps below: they have been superseded by this brief.
Written: 2026-10-27 15:56 UTC.
RE-VERIFY: This is a write-time snapshot. Run gh pr view https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/pull/743 --json headRefOid,state,statusCheckRollup before changing the shared branch. This author continuation has not verified the ARM correction or run the main/head256 drain comparison.
The2026-10-27 author brief says "Do NOT merge, enqueue, deploy." "Push normally to the shared PR branch (never force)." Run every targeted command as scripts/test.bash --local-and-remote --test <selector>, with at most one local test JVM on the shared machine. No full local suite, test timeout increases, iteration reductions, skipped/weakened assertions, unchanged CI retries or extra verification loops. Public fixes require assertion-red, first green and product-only reverted red. This author task has a90-minute wall-clock cap; the original handoff remains open for later review/landing.
The owner asked for every open handoff to be driven to completion. This author was asked to finish F3 ARM flags, compare the prepared256-case drain amplifier on main/head, and publish the established attribution table. The table is published in the why-first PR description. The shared PR remains OPEN at ae3e0c64168678d76be69f9caf3c759d046faa5e; no source was added to it by this continuation.
F3 source candidate0a7e6dcfd is pushed on WIP only. It selects the correct ARM versus Intel Linux directory/no-follow bits for both parent and leaf opens; descriptor closure is unchanged. Source/test review found no concrete composition defect. The prior ARM assertion-red was invalid as flag proof: both old and candidate executions failed at JDK SecureDirectoryStream with NoSuchFileException: tmp, before HeldDirectoryFileReader. QEMU7.2 -L maps every existing absolute path, including /, into its library sysroot, while absolute /tmp falls through to the host. Relative openat from the remapped root then cannot find tmp. A property-only aarch64 guard did not detect this mismatch. Full XML/stacks and the public source definitions are preserved.
Corrected execution uses QEMU -L /, which disables remapping, and an ignored copied ARM Java launcher whose PT_INTERP alone points to a task-owned ARM loader; ARM library paths are supplied separately. A new runtime guard checks actual aarch64 and opening the host temporary-directory ancestor relative to root. The still-queued script first requires that guard to fail on the old executor, then obtains old-product public assertion-red reaching the native reader, fixed4/4 first-attempt green (ARM/root and native x86 controls included), product-only reverted red using the identical executor, restores the source, then runs native main256/head256. It records actual red sets instead of guessing whether old parent flags reject before a linked leaf. Output labels must be fresh; source snapshots occur after rebase. No corrected-runtime or drain256 case had executed at this snapshot. The local shared-slot admission deadline expired once with zero cases; a final bounded admission remains active until before the author cap. This is a local resource wait, not a remote-test verdict.
Incoming-head full suite https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/actions/runs/40521197649 finished with1524 tests,1519 final passes/5 final failures and6 first failures. No CI job was requeued.
Five final failures show the earlier F2 fixture migration was incomplete: testJarHistoryUnpersistedRoutesSurviveWorkingSet, testJarHistoryReadDuringLaunchCleanup, testJarHistoryShutdownCleansInterruptedReadPin, testJarHistoryIndependentFilesystemsRecoverDuringStartup, testJarHistoryConcurrentStartupDuringDirectoryRead. Two still use generic SYSTEM wrappers refused by held-directory cleanup. Two startup hooks override entries while production calls FileSystem.list(root); the read-pin hook overrides deleteEntry while release calls ordinary FileSystem.delete(owner). Root-reviewed test-only corrections are pushed at84c356966, with every assertion/wait/iteration retained, NOT tested and NOT on the shared PR. The prior F1/F2 native10/10 cleanup proof remains valid for its selected cases; it did not prove all fixtures migrated.
testNurseryPidFile_rejectedReservationsHaveBoundedMemory also failed first, then passed its tool retry. At cycle4, its log says killProcess=true but the fixture isProcessAlive still=true; four prior retained-heap samples were flat. The fixture raw ProcessHandle override bypasses production SystemProcessChecker's explicit handling of exited processes awaiting collection. This is a likely observation mismatch, not a verified cause/fix or a pre-existing classification. Force that exact real process state through public APIs before changing code; do not loosen the guard or change its iterations/budget.
Failures/scenarios, including automatic tool histories: adoption head9/60/main9/60 (pre-existing); failed-probe12/60 vs25/60 (pre-existing); reused-request0/20 vs1/40 (also observed on main); external-store/metrics0/20 vs0/20 (original cause not established); drain2/60 vs0/20 (unresolved, requires256 comparison). Do not call drain unrelated from these counts.
| Branch | Remote SHA | PR/state |
|---|---|---|
| https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/fix/hd22-L80-no-orphan-sleep-helpers | ae3e0c64168678d76be69f9caf3c759d046faa5e | https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/pull/743 OPEN; incoming source unchanged; CI failed as above |
| https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w1-review9-20261027-1440 | 0a7e6dcfdbbf7c53d8bc3d1c43739ff246d70696 | No new PR; ARM candidate, not verified |
| https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w1-review9-fixtures-20261027 | 84c35696693b7c2fdce8f75417a33256ccf8d3ed | No PR; five test-only hook/capability corrections, not tested; based on ARM candidate |
| https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w1-review9-evidence-20261027-1430 | e759522015fd5875cee12cde7e17c4299003eca3 | No PR; full continuation evidence and executable sources; retains earlier evidence as parent |
| https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w1-review8-20261027-1304 | e231ccea403a325667ea6a24e1a49a561fb4beda | Prior candidate, superseded by equivalent0a7e6dcfd cherry-pick |
| https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w1-review8-evidence-20261027-1300 | a5d8beb54 (historical parent; recheck remote before using) | Prior raw cleanup evidence; its ARM-proof claim is superseded by this correction |
No code was merged, enqueued, deployed, restarted or published as an artifact. The command inventory contains repository work, tests/client preparation, read-only CI/package-source access and handoff metadata operations only. Runtime binaries, dependency caches and compiled helper classes are excluded deliberately. The exact package URLs/versions/SHA256 and reconstruction steps are now in review9/ARM-SETUP.md and arm-runtime-downloads.json; the previous parent claim that all URLs were in PROGRESS.md was incomplete.
Recorded agent work, including concurrent agents
135 h 56.6 min agent time · 8,748,657,433 tokens
1-hour columns · empty columns are idle gaps · UTC
| Series | Minutes | % minutes | Total tokens | % tokens | Output tokens | First active | Last active |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| W4-103110 · claude-opus-5-5 | 750.3 | 9.2% | 792,145,297 | 9.1% | 1,168,187 | ||
| W6-083925 · claude-opus-5-5 | 709.3 | 8.7% | 754,774,027 | 8.6% | 1,090,722 | ||
| W6-070636 · claude-opus-5-5 | 647.2 | 7.9% | 710,161,694 | 8.1% | 1,006,395 | ||
| W6-065126 · claude-opus-5-5 | 634.1 | 7.8% | 690,206,455 | 7.9% | 990,466 | ||
| W6-050404 · claude-opus-5-5 | 599.8 | 7.4% | 633,004,450 | 7.2% | 928,013 | ||
| W6-035934 · claude-opus-5-5 | 567.1 | 7.0% | 598,271,844 | 6.8% | 880,212 | ||
| W6-023034 · claude-opus-5-5 | 538.0 | 6.6% | 572,177,468 | 6.5% | 831,001 | ||
| W1-005426 · claude-opus-5-5 | 485.4 | 6.0% | 514,423,290 | 5.9% | 730,948 | ||
| W1-review23-author · claude-opus-5-5 | 467.8 | 5.7% | 490,191,809 | 5.6% | 704,024 | ||
| W1-232945 · claude-opus-5-5 | 449.6 | 5.5% | 465,935,780 | 5.3% | 667,956 | ||
| W1-review20 · claude-opus-5-5 | 419.3 | 5.1% | 425,412,503 | 4.9% | 610,648 | ||
| W1-review19 · claude-opus-5-5 | 385.5 | 4.7% | 404,684,232 | 4.6% | 565,934 | ||
| W1-review13 · claude-opus-5-5 | 278.7 | 3.4% | 318,608,581 | 3.6% | 430,079 | ||
| W1-173025 · claude-opus-5-5 | 262.3 | 3.2% | 295,634,984 | 3.4% | 398,898 | ||
| W1-155944 · claude-opus-5-5 | 241.8 | 3.0% | 278,623,843 | 3.2% | 353,827 | ||
| W1-review9-1430 · claude-opus-5-5 | 218.4 | 2.7% | 252,814,871 | 2.9% | 292,856 | ||
| W1-review8-1300 · claude-opus-5-5 | 190.5 | 2.3% | 210,458,904 | 2.4% | 247,349 | ||
| W1-103154-fix · claude-opus-5-5 | 137.0 | 1.7% | 148,952,820 | 1.7% | 172,722 | ||
| W1-review-fix-080657 · claude-opus-5-5 | 75.1 | 0.9% | 101,481,945 | 1.2% | 87,932 | ||
| fable-W1-1027 · claude-opus-5-5 | 45.6 | 0.6% | 58,439,482 | 0.7% | 52,803 | ||
| W1-155944 · gpt-6.1-sol (high) | 33.8 | 0.4% | 23,572,079 | 0.3% | 49,686 | ||
| W1-review19 · gpt-6.1-sol (high) | 9.4 | 0.1% | 3,930,447 | 0.0% | 18,663 | ||
| W1-review20 · gpt-6.1-sol (high) | 6.9 | 0.1% | 4,160,895 | 0.0% | 17,601 | ||
| L151 · claude-opus-5-5 | 3.7 | 0.0% | 589,733 | 0.0% | 4,766 |
Agent-minutes add across parallel agents. Tokens include input, cached input, cache writes and output. Percentages are rounded to one decimal place in text and may sum to slightly more or less than 100%.
d242821d
2026-10-28 11:42 UTC — DONE: fixed the review findings and pushed https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/pull/743. Freshly verified OPEN and unmerged at f4ae328ce43ca766ac1f1358b8d184142edbd4de.
Startup owns interrupted directory removals after their creator exits. Tests verify public recovery and cleanup outcomes. Pointer staging remains inside its owned generation.
Validation: 34/34 first-attempt passes and nine intended product-only reversed assertion failures, with 2,006 matching input hashes: https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/actions/runs/40679030155. The owner's bld-build full-suite gate remains. Requested result JSON and full native evidence are preserved at https://github.com/CodexCoder21Organization/ContainerNursery/tree/wip/w4-103110-evidence/review-evidence/w4-103110.
Delegated work at a glance: none. No blockers. No unnecessary holds. No idle landing gates. Owner direction captured: none new. Next steps for this author: none; the requested correction is complete. The broader handoff remains open for owner integration/review/landing, and the author claim is released.
Lessons: count directories as well as bytes; give intermediate rename states a future owner; verify the public pending-to-completed cleanup contract.
d242821d
d242821d
d242821d
d242821d
Moves it out of every priority list and into ArchiveArea.